Basement utility area comparing an older gas furnace with heat pump quote paperwork

Heat Pump Guide

Updated By Marcus Reed

Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace: 2026 Running Cost by State

Heat pump vs gas furnace on 2026 EIA rates: the break-even COP for all 50 states, installed cost, cold-climate limits, and when dual fuel wins.

Budget

Quick answer: On 2026 average utility rates, a heat pump costs less to run than a new 95% gas furnace in 7 states and is close in 11 more, mostly across the South and the Pacific Northwest. In the other 32 states the furnace wins on running cost unless the heat pump averages a seasonal COP above 3. Upfront, a gas furnace alone costs $3,800 to $10,000 installed against $12,000 to $18,000 for a ducted heat pump, but the heat pump also replaces the air conditioner. When the AC is due too, or your utility offers a heat pump rate, the math moves toward a heat pump or dual fuel.

Best for

US homeowners with natural gas service deciding between a new gas furnace, a heat pump, or a dual-fuel system, often with an aging AC in the same decision.

Wrong fit

Homes heating with propane, oil, or electric baseboard, commercial buildings, or anyone looking for a substitute for a contractor's load calculation.

Tradeoff

A heat pump replaces two machines and burns nothing on site, but where gas is cheap per therm, a high-efficiency furnace still delivers a unit of heat for less money.

Most heat pump vs furnace articles answer with an efficiency claim: a heat pump moves three units of heat for every unit of electricity, so it must be cheaper. Efficiency is not cost. What decides your heating bill is the price of a kilowatt-hour against the price of a therm where you live, and in 2026 that ratio varies across the country by more than a factor of three.

We ran the numbers for every state on current Energy Information Administration rates. The result is less one-sided than the marketing on either side: the heat pump wins clearly in the South and the Pacific Northwest, the furnace wins on running cost across most of the Midwest, Mountain West and Northeast, and a large group of states sits close enough that the specific equipment, your AC's age, and your utility's rate plan decide it.

Quick answer

Start with one number: your electricity rate in cents per kWh divided by your gas price in dollars per therm. At 15 cents and $1.50, that ratio is 10.

Your situationCheaper pathWhy
The ratio is under 8.6Heat pumpAn ENERGY STAR Cold Climate heat pump beats even a new 95% furnace on running cost
The ratio is 8.6 to 10.8Close: compare the exact equipmentThe heat pump needs a seasonal COP of 2.4 to 3.0, which good variable-speed equipment reaches in a mild or mixed climate
The ratio is over 10.8Gas furnace on running cost aloneThe heat pump needs a seasonal COP above 3.0, which few systems average over a real winter
Your central AC is also near the end of its lifePrice a heat pump against furnace plus ACOne heat pump replaces both machines, which closes most of the upfront gap
Your utility offers a winter heat pump rateRecalculate with that rateIn Massachusetts the 2025 to 2026 heat pump rate cut the break-even COP from 3.5 to about 2.6
Gas is cheap but you need new cooling anywayDual fuelThe heat pump handles cooling and mild heating days, the furnace takes the coldest hours

The ratio thresholds assume a new 95% AFUE furnace. Against an older 80% furnace, the heat pump wins in twice as many states. The method behind every number is below, and you can repeat it with the rates printed on your own bills.

How we compared them

We compared the cost of delivering the same amount of heat into the house, one million BTU, from each system. Both systems use the same ductwork in this comparison, so duct losses cancel out.

  • Electricity price: EIA's average residential price by state, year to date through July 2026 (Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.B). This includes the winter months when heating load is highest.
  • Natural gas price: EIA's 2025 annual average residential price by state, in dollars per thousand cubic feet. Monthly gas prices swing hard with the season, so the full-year average is the fairer figure. EIA has not published a 2025 annual figure for Connecticut, Maine, Maryland, North Carolina, Rhode Island and South Carolina, so those six use 2024 and are marked with an asterisk.
  • Conversion: EIA's own factor of 1,037 BTU per cubic foot, which makes one thousand cubic feet equal to 10.37 therms.
  • Furnace efficiency: 95% AFUE for a new condensing furnace and 80% AFUE for a standard or older one.
  • Heat pump efficiency: expressed as seasonal COP, the average heat delivered per unit of electricity over a whole heating season, including defrost and cold snaps.
  • Hawaii is left out because almost no homes there buy space heating.

Last checked October 15, 2026. Average residential prices include fixed monthly customer charges, which matters for how you read the results. We cover that in the section on what we could not verify.

The one formula behind the comparison

A gas furnace turns one therm (100,000 BTU) into heat at its AFUE rating. A heat pump turns one kWh (3,412 BTU) into heat at its COP. Set the two costs equal and you get the COP a heat pump has to beat to cost less to run:

Break-even COP = 0.293 × furnace AFUE × (electricity in cents per kWh) ÷ (gas in dollars per therm)

In practice that is a two-step calculation:

  1. Divide your electricity rate in cents by your gas price per therm.
  2. Multiply by 0.28 if you are comparing against a 95% furnace, or by 0.23 against an 80% furnace.

Georgia is a quick example. Electricity averages 15.4 cents and gas $1.97 per therm. 15.4 divided by 1.97 is 7.8, and 7.8 times 0.28 is 2.2. Any heat pump that averages a seasonal COP above 2.2 heats a Georgia home for less than a new condensing furnace. In Illinois the same steps give 19.2 divided by 1.08, times 0.28, which comes to about 5. Almost no heat pump averages that over an Illinois winter.

What COP can you actually expect?

Heat pumps are not sold on seasonal COP. They are rated on HSPF2, the heating season efficiency in BTU per watt-hour. Divide HSPF2 by 3.412 and you have the season-long COP the rating implies.

EquipmentHSPF2 ratingImplied seasonal COP
Federal minimum for a split-system heat pump (since 2023)7.52.2
ENERGY STAR split system7.82.3
ENERGY STAR Cold Climate, ducted8.12.4
ENERGY STAR Cold Climate, ductless8.52.5
High-efficiency variable-speed ducted, such as Bosch IDS Ultra or Daikin FIT Auroraup to 10up to 2.9
Top ductless ratings, such as Fujitsu AIRSTAGE Orion XLTHup to 13.3up to 3.9

One caution. HSPF2 is calculated for DOE's mixed-climate test region. In a colder region the real seasonal COP lands below the implied figure, and in a warmer one it lands above. That is why a break-even COP of 2.4 is an easy win in Texas and a harder one in Minnesota.

How much electricity replaces your gas use

To translate your own gas bill, use this table. Find your annual heating therms on last winter's bills, divide by 100, and multiply by the figure for your furnace and the heat pump's expected COP.

Your current furnacekWh per 100 therms at COP 2.0at COP 2.5at COP 3.0
95% AFUE1,3921,114928
80% AFUE1,172938782

A home that burns 800 therms a year in an 80% furnace would use about 7,500 kWh with a heat pump averaging COP 2.5. At Illinois averages that is roughly $1,440 of electricity against $870 of gas. A Georgia home burning 400 therms in an 80% furnace would use about 3,750 kWh, roughly $580 against $790 of gas. Both are illustrations at state average rates, not quotes.

Heat pump vs gas furnace at a glance

FactorGas furnaceHeat pump
How it makes heatBurns natural gas at 80% to about 98% AFUEMoves heat from outdoor air; seasonal COP of roughly 2 to 4 depending on equipment and climate
What it replacesHeating only; central AC is a separate machineHeating and cooling in one system
Installed cost, 2026$3,800 to $10,000 for the furnace alone$12,000 to $18,000 for a ducted system on usable ducts
Running costLower wherever gas is cheap per therm, see the state tablesLower wherever electricity is cheap relative to gas
Cold-weather outputFull output at any outdoor temperatureFalls as it gets colder; ENERGY STAR Cold Climate units must keep at least 70% of rated capacity at 5°F
On-site combustionYes: needs venting, a gas line, and a working carbon monoxide alarmNone
Electrical workStandard circuit for the blower and controlsDedicated 240V circuit; sometimes a panel upgrade at $1,500 to $4,000
Fuel price exposureGas prices and the fixed monthly gas customer chargeElectricity rates, including any heat pump or winter rate your utility offers
Federal tax credit in 2026NoneNone: the 25C credit ended for equipment placed in service after December 31, 2025

Running cost by state, 2026

The two COP columns show the seasonal COP a heat pump needs to beat a new 95% furnace and an older 80% furnace on running cost. Lower is better for the heat pump. The gas and power columns are the EIA prices behind each figure. For the U.S. as a whole, electricity averages 18.2 cents per kWh and gas $1.48 per therm, which gives a break-even COP of 3.4 against a 95% furnace and 2.9 against an 80% furnace.

States where a heat pump costs less to run (7)

A break-even COP of 2.4 or below means an ENERGY STAR Cold Climate heat pump beats even a new condensing furnace on its rating alone.

StateCOP vs 95% furnaceCOP vs 80% furnaceGas, $/thermPower, ¢/kWh
Florida1.71.5$2.4615.3
Arkansas2.01.7$1.8613.6
Georgia2.21.8$1.9715.4
Louisiana2.21.9$1.6813.3
Arizona2.42.0$1.7915.4
Texas2.42.0$1.8716.1
Washington2.42.0$1.7014.4

States where it is close (11)

A break-even COP between 2.5 and 3.0 is within reach of high-efficiency variable-speed equipment in a mild or mixed climate, and easy against an 80% furnace.

StateCOP vs 95% furnaceCOP vs 80% furnaceGas, $/thermPower, ¢/kWh
Mississippi2.62.2$1.6115.2
North Carolina*2.62.2$1.5814.9
Alabama2.72.3$1.6916.5
Missouri2.72.3$1.4414.0
Oklahoma2.72.3$1.3913.6
Oregon2.72.2$1.6115.4
South Carolina*2.72.3$1.6315.9
Kentucky2.92.4$1.3714.3
Virginia2.92.4$1.6216.8
Kansas3.02.5$1.4315.2
Nevada3.02.5$1.2713.5

States where gas costs less to run (32)

A break-even COP above 3.0 is beyond what most heat pumps average over a real heating season. In these states the case for a heat pump rests on cooling, dual fuel, a heat pump electric rate, or reasons other than the heating bill.

StateCOP vs 95% furnaceCOP vs 80% furnaceGas, $/thermPower, ¢/kWh
Delaware3.22.7$1.5417.9
West Virginia3.22.7$1.3315.5
Nebraska3.32.8$1.1012.9
Tennessee3.42.8$1.1413.9
Wyoming3.42.9$1.1313.9
Massachusetts3.52.9$2.4230.1
Utah3.73.1$0.9813.2
Maryland*3.83.2$1.5621.3
North Dakota3.83.2$0.9212.4
Vermont3.83.2$1.7423.9
Iowa3.93.3$1.0214.2
Ohio3.93.3$1.3418.7
Rhode Island*3.93.3$2.0929.2
Pennsylvania4.03.4$1.4521.0
New Hampshire4.23.5$1.7926.8
South Dakota4.23.6$0.9514.5
Colorado4.33.6$1.0816.7
District of Columbia4.33.6$1.6124.7
Indiana4.33.6$1.1117.0
Minnesota4.33.6$1.0616.2
California4.43.7$2.1233.2
New Mexico4.43.7$0.9515.1
Montana4.53.8$0.8713.9
Maine*4.63.8$1.8330.0
Connecticut*4.84.0$1.6228.0
New York4.84.1$1.7029.4
Idaho4.94.1$0.7413.0
Illinois4.94.2$1.0819.2
New Jersey4.94.1$1.3724.0
Wisconsin5.14.3$1.0419.0
Michigan5.74.8$1.0521.5
Alaska6.05.1$1.2527.1

* Gas price is the 2024 annual average because EIA has not published a 2025 annual figure for this state.

Heat Pump Guide

Want a second read on the quote?

Paste the proposal or upload the PDF. No lead auction.

Free. No sales pitch. Personal reply in ~2 business days.

Still researching? Send me the guide

What the state tables show

  • The South and Southwest favor the heat pump. Gas is expensive per therm there, partly because fixed monthly charges are spread over little winter use, and winters are mild enough that the heat pump runs near its best COP most of the season.
  • The Pacific Northwest favors the heat pump on cheap electricity. In Washington, electricity at 14.4 cents per kWh against gas at $1.70 per therm is the reason, not the climate.
  • The Midwest and Mountain West favor gas. Gas at $0.74 to $1.11 per therm in Idaho, Utah, the Dakotas, Iowa, Minnesota, Colorado and Indiana sets a bar of COP 3.7 to 4.9 that few heat pumps clear on a season average.
  • The Northeast and California favor gas on average rates, for a different reason. Gas is not cheap there, but electricity is even more expensive, at about 24 to 33 cents per kWh across New England, New York, New Jersey and California. That is exactly where heat pump electric rates matter most.

None of this says a heat pump is a bad buy in a gas-favoring state. It says the heating bill alone will not pay for the switch there, so the decision has to rest on the cooling replacement, dual fuel, comfort, or a lower electric rate.

Massachusetts: what a heat pump rate does to the math

Massachusetts is one of this site's priority markets, and it shows how much a rate plan can change the answer. Since November 1, 2025, the state's investor-owned utilities have offered seasonal heat pump rates that lower the base distribution charge from November through April. At Eversource, the 2025 to 2026 rates also lowered the winter transmission charge. Together those two lines came to about 7 cents per kWh less than the standard residential rate.

Massachusetts scenarioElectricity, ¢/kWhCOP to beat a 95% furnaceCOP to beat an 80% furnace
Standard residential average30.13.52.9
With the 2025 to 2026 Eversource heat pump rateabout 22.92.62.2

With the heat pump rate, a cold-climate heat pump replacing an 80% furnace moves from roughly break-even to a likely saving, and against a new 95% furnace it moves from a clear loss to close. We could not confirm the approved rates for the 2026 to 2027 season, so check the current figures with your utility. Households that install through Mass Save are enrolled automatically. If you heat with oil or propane instead, the comparison is much easier for the heat pump; see heat pump vs oil heat and heat pump vs propane heat, and for incentives, Massachusetts heat pump cost and rebates.

Installed cost: what each path costs up front

ProjectTypical 2026 installed costWhat it covers
Gas furnace replacement$3,800 to $10,000Furnace only, per Carrier's 2026 guide citing Angi; higher-efficiency units and venting changes push toward the top
3-ton central AC replacement$6,000 to $9,800 at standard tierOur sister site's published planning band for a clean straight swap, from aircondition.guide
Furnace plus AC, priced as two jobs$9,800 to $19,800The two bands above added together; one combined install often shares some labor
Ducted heat pump, usable ducts$12,000 to $18,000Outdoor unit, air handler or coil, line set, controls; from our heat pump buying guide
Whole-home cold-climate heat pump with duct or electrical work$18,000 to $25,000 and upSame source; includes the projects where ducts or the panel need work
Panel upgrade, if needed$1,500 to $4,000More when the meter or service entrance is involved; see the panel upgrade guide

Two things change this table in practice.

The AC's age. If your central AC has years left, you are comparing a $3,800 to $10,000 furnace against a $12,000 to $18,000 heat pump, and the furnace is far cheaper up front. If the AC is also near the end of its life, the comparison becomes furnace plus AC against one heat pump, and the ranges overlap almost entirely.

Incentives. There is no federal tax credit for either path in 2026: the 25C credit applies only to equipment placed in service through December 31, 2025, as explained in heat pump tax credit 2026. State and utility programs remain, but they differ on whether natural gas counts as an eligible fuel to displace. Energize CT, for example, names natural gas alongside oil, propane and electric resistance; other programs pay more, or only, when the heat pump replaces oil, propane or electric resistance. Confirm the rule for your program before a quote subtracts a rebate.

Climate: will a heat pump keep the house warm?

Running cost is one question. Capacity on the coldest night is another, and the quote has to answer both.

A heat pump's output and COP both fall as the outdoor temperature drops. ENERGY STAR's Cold Climate criteria require a COP of at least 1.75 at 5°F and at least 70% of rated heating capacity at 5°F, and good cold-climate models hold 70 to 100% at that temperature. Standard models can lose 40 to 50% of their capacity by 5°F. The details are in heat pump efficiency by outdoor temperature and cold-climate heat pumps.

What matters for your house is the heat loss at your local design temperature, the coldest condition your area normally sees. Ask for a Manual J load calculation and the quoted model's capacity at that temperature. Our guide to verifying heat pump output at your design temperature lists design temperatures for 57 metro areas and walks through the check. If the heat pump cannot carry the full load, the design needs backup heat, and the quote should price it.

Dual fuel: the answer for many gas-favoring states

A dual-fuel system pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace. The heat pump heats on mild days and handles all the cooling, and the furnace takes over below a set outdoor temperature.

The break-even COP tells you where to set that switchover. A heat pump's COP is highest on mild days and drops as it gets colder, so the economic switchover is the outdoor temperature where the heat pump's COP falls below your break-even COP. In a state with a break-even around 2.5 to 3.0, that point often lands near freezing for a modern variable-speed unit, and the heat pump carries a large share of the season. Check it against the quoted model's published COP table rather than assuming. In a state with a break-even of 4 or more, the heat pump only beats gas on the mildest days, and dual fuel is mostly a way to get efficient cooling with a furnace that does the real winter work.

Dual fuel makes the most sense when the furnace is healthy, roughly 10 to 12 years old or newer, and the AC is the machine that failed. The repair or replace guide covers that case, and the backup heat guide explains how switchover controls work.

How to decide in five steps

  1. Pull two numbers from your bills. Divide a winter gas bill's total by the therms used to get an all-in price per therm, and do the same with the electric bill for cents per kWh. Your own numbers beat any state average.
  2. Calculate your break-even COP. Use the formula above with 0.28 for a new condensing furnace or 0.23 for an 80% furnace.
  3. Compare it with the quoted equipment. Ask for the exact model's HSPF2, and its capacity and COP at 17°F and 5°F. Divide HSPF2 by 3.412 and adjust down for a cold climate.
  4. Put cooling in the comparison. If the AC is more than 12 to 15 years old, price furnace plus AC against a heat pump, not furnace against heat pump.
  5. Compare quotes on the same scope. Sizing method, electrical work, backup heat, ducts and rebate assumptions should match before price means anything. Our guide to reading a heat pump quote shows what each line should say.

Quote red flags

  • A savings estimate that does not show the electricity and gas rates it assumed.
  • "Heat pumps are 300% efficient, so you will cut your heating bill by two thirds," with no mention of your gas price.
  • A 2026 federal tax credit subtracted from the price. The 25C credit ended for equipment placed in service after December 31, 2025.
  • Tonnage picked from square footage, with no Manual J or documented load basis.
  • Backup heat assumed but not priced, controlled, or explained.
  • A brand name with no exact outdoor and indoor model numbers, AHRI match, or low-temperature capacity.
  • A rebate shown as a guaranteed discount, or one that assumes your program pays for displacing natural gas without saying so.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?

It depends on your electricity and gas prices more than on the equipment. On 2026 average rates, a heat pump costs less to run than a new 95% furnace in 7 states, including Florida, Georgia, Texas and Washington, and is close in 11 more. In 32 states, cheap gas makes a condensing furnace cheaper per unit of heat. Divide your electricity rate in cents by your gas price per therm and multiply by 0.28: if the heat pump's seasonal COP is above that number, it costs less to run.

Is a heat pump worth it if I have cheap natural gas?

Not on heating bills alone. With gas around $1 per therm, as across much of the Midwest and Mountain West, the heat pump needs a seasonal COP of roughly 3.3 to nearly 6 to beat a 95% furnace, which few systems average over a real winter. A heat pump can still make sense there when the AC also needs replacing, as part of a dual-fuel system, or when your utility offers a discounted heat pump rate.

Will a heat pump keep my house warm in a cold climate?

A correctly sized cold-climate heat pump can. ENERGY STAR Cold Climate models must deliver a COP of at least 1.75 and at least 70% of rated capacity at 5°F, and many hold more. The quote should show a Manual J load calculation and the model's capacity at your local design temperature, and it should price backup heat if the heat pump cannot carry the full load.

Should I replace a working gas furnace with a heat pump?

Usually not for savings alone in a gas-favoring state. The stronger move is to wait until the furnace or the AC needs replacing, then price both paths. If only the AC has failed and the furnace is healthy, a dual-fuel heat pump in place of the AC keeps the furnace as backup and adds efficient heating on mild days.

How much more does a heat pump cost than a gas furnace?

A gas furnace alone typically costs $3,800 to $10,000 installed in 2026, against $12,000 to $18,000 for a ducted heat pump on usable ducts. The gap mostly closes when the central AC also needs replacing, because a heat pump replaces both: a furnace plus a 3-ton AC priced as two jobs runs about $9,800 to $19,800.

What is dual fuel, and when does it make sense?

Dual fuel pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace. The heat pump handles cooling and mild heating days, and the furnace takes over below a switchover temperature. It makes the most sense in states where gas is cheap, when the furnace is healthy and the AC needs replacing. Set the switchover where the heat pump's COP drops below your break-even COP.

What we could not verify

  • Your marginal rates. EIA's averages include fixed monthly customer charges. If you keep gas for a stove or water heater, you keep paying the gas customer charge, so the gas you stop buying is cheaper than the average suggests and the heat pump case is weaker than our tables show. If you disconnect gas entirely, you drop that charge, and the average is the fairer figure. Your own bills settle it.
  • Real seasonal COP in your climate. HSPF2 is calculated for DOE's mixed-climate test region. We did not model climate-specific seasonal COP for each state, so treat the implied COP figures as an upper bound in cold states.
  • 2025 gas prices for six states. EIA has not published 2025 annual residential gas prices for Connecticut, Maine, Maryland, North Carolina, Rhode Island and South Carolina. We used their 2024 averages.
  • Massachusetts 2026 to 2027 heat pump rates. National Grid filed revised heat pump rates for November 1, 2026 in D.P.U. 26-71, and we could not confirm the approved figures for any utility. Our example uses Eversource's 2025 to 2026 figures.
  • A verified national installed price. No federal agency publishes installed residential HVAC prices. The furnace range is a manufacturer's published range citing Angi, and the heat pump and AC ranges are this network's own planning bands. Your written quotes are the real numbers.

Sources

All sources checked October 15, 2026.

Methodology

These guides are built from public specifications, primary program pages, utility documentation, manufacturer materials, and repeated buyer questions that show up in quote and installation decisions.

Manufacturer and installer responses can clarify pricing bands, warranty terms, support footprint, and common mistakes. They do not move a page up the shortlist on their own.

Written by Marcus ReedReviewed by Heat Pump Guide Editorial Team, Editorial review on October 15, 2026How we reviewEditorial policy

Next Step

What to do next

Use one of these three paths. They are here to move the decision forward, not add more noise.

Want the full buyer path in your inbox? We send the short version.

Related Guides